• 57°

Modern Conservatism Is An Alliance

By JOHN HOOD

RALEIGH — Isn’t “modern conservatism” a contradiction in terms? That’s one of the questions I received after teaching a seminar at Duke University’s Sanford School of Public Policy entitled “Modern Conservatism and Policy.”

No, modern conservatism is a real thing. It has deep roots in human experience and intellectual history, to be sure. But the modern conservative movement, both here in North Carolina and across the country, is quite a different animal from what would have been called conservatism a century ago. (It’s also quite different from one might call the “postmodern quasi-conservatism” currently being displayed by certain interest groups, media outlets, and politicians.)

Like all intellectual and political movements, modern conservatism is an alliance of people who have enough in common to justify working together as well as enough not in common to produce ongoing tensions, passionate debates, and the occasional public rupture.

There is no one group of people — not anywhere, at any point in time — who are both a consistent majority of the population and in consistent agreement on every major issue. That’s why all parties and movements are, inevitably, coalitions. Conservatism has its stresses and strains. But so do progressive and populist movements, as has been evident among Democrats since the 2016 presidential primaries.

Who populates the modern conservative movement? There are three main groups: traditionalists, libertarians, and pragmatists. The traditionalist camp, sometimes called social conservatives or the Religious Right, believes there are certain principles, practices, and institutions that maximize human flourishing. These are either the creations of God or have proven their value over the course of human history.

Big government injures and supplants these traditional institutions of family, faith, and community, say these conservatives, who argue that while all individuals enjoy moral worth and dignity, they are part of broader communities they didn’t choose, from which they receive benefits, and to which they have obligations. Governments exist because humans are easily tempted by vice, these conservatives contend. They prioritize moral issues such as abortion, marriage, and substance abuse.

The next group, the libertarians, can also be called economic conservatives. Originally, they were called (and called themselves) liberals, because their core political value was liberty. To protect individual rights to life, liberty, and property, they argue for a limited government that would deter force and fraud and ensure the provision of certain services that could not effectively be produced within private markets. These conservatives prioritize lower taxes, lighter regulations, and more choice and competition in public services.

Libertarians emphasize that societies are complex interactions among individuals, families, associations, and institutions. No one does or can possess the information necessary to design or manage societies. Attempts to do so will produce unforeseen and adverse consequences.

The other constituents of the movement, pragmatists, are often labeled neoconservatives — although not to the same intended effect. Some leftists use the term as a charge of extremism, perhaps because it shares a prefix with “neo-Nazi.” Conservatives use it, more accurately, to describe an initial wave of thinkers and politicians who began as progressives or socialists, got “mugged by reality” as prominent neoconservative Irving Kristol once put it, and changed their views.

Many but not all neoconservatives were foreign-policy hawks, first during the Cold War and then after 9/11. Others emphasized social policy. They criticized the 1960s War on Poverty, for example, for discouraging work and family formation, and for unnecessarily muscling aside local, private, and faith-based approaches to addressing social ills and promoting economic opportunity.

Despite important differences in abstract principles and practical priorities, traditionalists, libertarians, and pragmatists work together within modern conservatism in part because they often share the same political adversaries. There is something else binding these discrete groups together, however: a strong belief that human nature is a significant and persistent constraint on human action.

Want a modern, if perhaps unintended, statement of this core conservative tenet? “You can’t always get what you want,” wrote Mick Jagger and Keith Richards. “But if you try sometimes, you just might find you get what you need.”

–––

John Hood (@JohnHoodNC) is chairman of the John Locke Foundation and appears on “NC SPIN,” broadcast statewide Fridays at 7:30p and Sundays at 12:30p on UNC-TV.

News

UPDATED: Dare County Schools staffer tests positive for COVID-19, six Manteo Elementary students quarantined

Business

‘Keep the Cheer Here’ campaign encourages local shopping

Lifestyles

Don’t get tricked: Stay safe on Halloween

News

Travel trailer park rules approved for unincorporated Dare County

News

COVID-19 testing date set in Nags Head

News

NC Wildlife officers, Coast Guard come to aid of sailboat operator in Albemarle Sound

News

North Carolina, Virginia Maryland announce collaboration to advance offshore wind projects

News

Supreme Court leaves North Carolina absentee ballot deadline at Nov. 12

News

Lawsuit says census takers were pressured to falsify data

News

NOAA Fisheries announces changes to transit provisions for shrimp fishery

News

Flags at half-staff to honor U.S. Coast Guard Ensign Morgan Garrett

Lifestyles

It’s a girl! Aquarium staff caring for sandbar shark pup born October 16

Lifestyles

Yes, Virginia Dare, there will be a Santa Claus – but no parade

Lifestyles

Gathering of gators at Alligator River National Wildlife Refuge

Hyde

Fried shrimp fundraising lunch and dinner set at Swan Quarter Volunteer Fire Department

News

Zeta re-strengthens to a hurricane, takes aim at Gulf Coast

News

Dare commissioners push forward on essential housing

Currituck

Breakfast: The most important meal of the day

Currituck

Currituck Extension holding on-demand virtual food preservation series

News

North Carolina to get over 3 million BinaxNOW rapid coronavirus tests

News

Organizations and individuals join to support victims of Buxton fire

Crime

Second degree murder charges filed for death of Kitty Hawk woman

News

DEQ awards $11.5 million in storm damage grants

Crime

Tolson charged with second degree murder in death of LeeAnn Fletcher