• 77°

Opinion: Public won’t accept green taxes

by John Hood

I know that environmental activists don’t want to hear this, but a core component of their preferred strategy for combatting global warming – substantially raising the price of fossil fuels through higher taxes – is not going to happen.

Whatever the public’s views may be about the causes and effects of climate change, most people don’t think gas prices and electric rates are too low. While modest price increases to cover higher production costs, or modestly higher taxes to fund road and bridge construction, may not provoke a massive backlash, the dramatic hikes in prices that environmental groups want to discourage the use of fossil fuels are just politically unsustainable.

Don’t take my word for it. Look at recent events in two left-leaning political constituencies: the state of Washington and the country of France.

In November, even as Washington Democrats were winning most of the competitive races in that state, 56 percent of Washington voters said no to a ballot proposition that would have imposed a carbon tax to combat global warming. The tax would have started at $15 a metric ton and then increased $2 a year until the state’s goals for greenhouse-gas emissions were met.

After a previous carbon-tax scheme failed in 2016, activists had retooled the plan to draw more support. The 2018 initiative exempted some key employers in Washington State, such as paper plants, to mute opposition from labor unions. It promised to spend the proceeds on renewable-energy projects to create jobs. And if the truth be told, as costly as the proposed tax would have been for Washington consumers, it was far lower than the price hike most scholars believe would be necessary truly to shift energy markets away from fossil fuels.

But Washington’s voters said no, anyway. They didn’t judge any environmental benefits that might flow from the carbon tax in the long run to be worth the cost, and they didn’t trust that the resulting revenue would have been spent effectively. The voters were right on both counts.

In France, the recent revolt against green taxes played out not in polling places but on the streets. The “yellow vest” movement began as opposition to higher “green taxes” on gasoline and diesel, with hundreds of thousands ultimately turning out in protests that produced widespread economic disruptions, political disaster for President Emmanuel Macron and his coalition and even several tragic deaths. In response, Macron has walked back scheduled hikes in motor-fuels taxes and may soon be forced to go further than that.

It is important to understand that in neither case can the opposition be characterized as tea-party conservatives or climate-change skeptics. There aren’t enough such voters in Washington to have defeated the carbon tax multiple times. In France, the yellow-vest protestors are advancing a range of demands, including traditionally left-wing fare such as raising minimum wages and enhancing government pensions.

If activists can’t find the votes to jack up green taxes enough to matter in places such as Washington and France, you can be sure they will fall far short in North Carolina, where public opposition to tax increases of any kind is broader and deeper.

A few weeks ago, Gov. Roy Cooper announced a goal of reducing greenhouse-gas emissions in North Carolina 40 percent by the year 2025. Cooper’s target is quite a bit less than initially meets the eye, since the 40 percent reduction is from the 2005 baseline, not from 2018. Our emissions have already fallen by 25 percent since 2005, so Cooper’s real goal is an additional 15 percent.

While North Carolina has been tipping the scales heavily in favor of renewables, that’s not the main reason emissions have declined. Wind and solar remain a very small part of our energy mix. The big stories are gains in energy efficiency plus a large-scale replacement of coal-fired power plants with electricity from cleaner-burning natural gas.

Activists still dream of carbon taxes and a massive abandonment of fossil fuels. Once they awaken, a realistic conversation may be possible.

John Hood is chairman of the conservative John Locke Foundation.

FOR MORE COLUMNS AND LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, CLICK HERE.

Currituck

Ben Stikeleather stepping down as Currituck’s county manager

Hyde

Cape Hatteras National Seashore opens Ocracoke Island Discovery Center

Crime

North Carolina man sentenced to 30 months in prison for attempting to set police vehicle on fire

News

Parental consent for children’s COVID-19 vaccine included in legislation approved by NC Senate

Currituck

‘Honorary grandmother’ of Corolla wild horse herd dies

News

Motorcycle crash claims life of North Carolina man

News

North Carolina lottery sales bring in record haul for education

Crime

Kill Devil Hills man sentenced to over 10 years in prison for cocaine charge

Lifestyles

Assembly of Praise to hold children’s event Saturday

News

Manteo department leaders report on prior month’s activity

News

Kitty Hawk recreation master plan gets vote of approval

News

Black sea bass fishery opens Friday

Crime

North Carolina police looking for man accused of running over driver after stealing car

News

UPDATED: Kayaker dies off Haulover Sound Access north of Buxton

News

Three shot in North Carolina road rage incident; child among those injured

Lifestyles

GEM: Helping people living with dementia stay home longer

Crime

Teen girl killed in North Carolina hit-and-run crash

Crime

Man residing in North Carolina charged with naturalization fraud

Currituck

Maritime Museum now open in Historic Corolla Park

News

Manteo considers adding New Year’s Eve as town-sponsored event

Crime

North Carolina man sentenced to prison, supervised release for firearm charge

Crime

Former North Carolina game room employee charged in shooting

News

North Carolina lawn mower rider killed in road collision

News

Going up: North Carolina gas prices rise after short-lived decrease