• 75°

NC court order threatens executive branch power over funds

By Gary D. Robertson, Associated Press

A North Carolina Court of Appeals panel’s ruling threatens the ability of elected executive branch leaders in the state to control non-tax dollars without legislative permission.

The panel’s majority ruled this week that Democratic Attorney General Josh Stein had to deposit money paid annually by Smithfield Foods as part agreement reached in 2000 over hog waste and any residual into the state’s coffers.

The money — up to $2 million annually provided by Smithfield — had been held in a private bank account for use in distributing grants designed to enhance the state’s environment. Democratic attorneys general — now-Gov. Roy Cooper and Stein — have selected grant recipients based on a panel’s recommendations.

In April, the state Supreme Court ruled 6-1 that the Smithfield payments are not civil penalties, leaving the Smithfield arrangement intact. As such, the justices wrote, the money is not required to be spent on public schools, as the state constitution would otherwise require. The New Hanover County school board, a plaintiff in a lawsuit that began in 2016, had argued the money had to be earmarked for schools.

But a November 2019 law approved by the Republican-controlled legislature directed that all cash gifts and donations to the state or for the state’s benefit “shall be deposited into the state treasury.” While the General Assembly decides how money in the treasury is spent, last year’s law says such gifts still must be used in line with the donor’s agreed-to purpose.

The Court of Appeals panel reviewed the lawsuit again in light of the state Supreme Court decision and the 2019 law. Department of Justice lawyers representing Stein told the court in September that it had completed moving all of the payments since July 2019 to the treasury.

Judge John Tyson, writing the majority opinion released Tuesday, agreed that “the statute clearly mandates these are public funds, they belong to the taxpayers of this State, and are required” to be put into the state treasury.

Judge Phil Berger Jr. agreed with Tyson. Judge Wanda Bryant wrote a dissenting opinion, saying how the 2019 law affects the Smithfield funds is a matter for a trial court to determine. The state Supreme Court would be obligated to hear the case again if requested because it was a split decision.

Paul Stam, an attorney representing the school board, praised Tuesday’s decision, which he said could affect up to $12 million in payments from Smithfield. The 25-year agreement originally penned by then-Attorney General Mike Easley, Smithfield and several of its subsidiaries, will end in the mid-2020s.

Stein spokesperson Laura Brewer said the Justice Department was reviewing Tuesday’s opinion. The Court of Appeals did not say specifically whether Stein still has authority to distribute the Smithfield funds even when they’re now in state coffers.

Stam contends that should the ruling stand, the legislature would have control over how the payments are spent as long as they address environmental enhancement.

“The AG will no longer be able to operate what is in effect a slush fund,” Stam, a former Republican state House leader, said in an interview. Stam said the money could address environmental improvements at schools.

The 2000 deal came a year after Hurricane Floyd caused dozens of hog waste pits to overflow. Smithfield also had paid one of the largest water-quality fines in state history after waste spills at two hog operations.

READ ABOUT MORE NEWS HERE.

RECENT HEADLINES:

Rodanthe bridge finish delayed

Stith named to lead North Carolina community college system

Lifestyles

Nags Head Ocean Rescue places third overall, second in division at lifesaving competition

News

Citizens appointed to Dare boards, commission

Crime

Two men, one woman arrested in North Carolina after 14 neglected dogs seized, four more found dead

News

One killed, another injured in North Carolina train, truck crash

Lifestyles

First Flight Market takes off in Kill Devil Hills

Crime

North Carolina man cited after toddler rescued from porch roof

Crime

Four from North Carolina indicted for various drug, fraud charges

Currituck

Currituck-Knotts Island ferry route to suspend service Tuesday through Friday

Hyde

Hyde County Courthouse bell project made possible with community support

Crime

Newport News man arrested on charges related to Currituck County road rage incident

News

Sunday night wreck in Frisco results in fatality

News

Feeling sleepy? Bear cub takes a break at Pocosin Lakes National Wildlife Refuge

News

North Carolina gas prices fall slightly over past week

Lifestyles

Fishing on the Alligator River National Wildlife Refuge

Crime

North Carolina man charged with murder in drive-by shooting of teen girl

Hyde

Airplane flips after landing at Ocracoke airport

Crime

North Carolina police investigating drive-by shooting that claimed life of 12-year-old

Crime

Virginia man arrested for domestic assault in Rodanthe

News

William B. Umstead Bridge speed limit temporarily lowered for purple martins

Crime

Virginia man arrested in Nags Head after traffic stop

Lifestyles

Outer Banks Anglers Club to hear from artificial reef coordinator at next meeting

Crime

Former North Carolina resident sentenced to prison for bribery, visa fraud, tax charges

Hyde

Drone trial delivers supplies to Ocracoke Island

News

Comments open on proposed Buxton and Avon nourishment projects